This article separates the introduced bill text and official records from attributed industry estimates. Sources and limitations appear below.

The Stop Auto Fraud Act of 2026 is a proposed federal bill that would criminalize knowingly causing, staging, fabricating, or simulating a motor vehicle accident as part of a scheme to submit a false insurance claim. The introduced text proposes a fine, up to 10 years in prison, or both for the base offense; a fine, up to 20 years in prison, or both if serious bodily injury results; and a fine, imprisonment for any term of years or life, or both if death results. Introduced September 3, 2026, it has not been enacted and does not require lower premiums.

Key Findings

  • What it would do: Create a federal offense for knowingly staging or simulating a crash as part of a scheme to submit a fraudulent insurance claim. Proposed prison terms are up to 10 years, up to 20 years if serious bodily injury results, and any term of years or life if death results; fines are also allowed.
  • What it does not do: It does not set rates, cap premiums, or require reductions. The introduced text has no effective date because the bill is still a proposal.
  • Fraud-cost estimates: Insurance Journal attributes an estimate of up to $300 a year in added premiums from staged-crash fraud to the National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB); its method was not available and it is not a bill-specific forecast. Clearspeed modeled $31.6 billion in annual U.S. personal-auto costs from fraud and inaccurate information; it is not a count of confirmed claims.
  • What to do now: Do not change coverage decisions based on this proposal. Review your renewal, deductibles, and UM/UIM coverage, and check how your state accepts fraud reports.

Navigate This Guide

What Does the Stop Auto Fraud Act of 2026 Actually Do?

The bill would add an offense to Title 18 of the U.S. Code. The introduced text covers knowingly causing, staging, fabricating, or simulating a motor vehicle accident and submitting a false insurance claim for losses such as medical treatment, repairs, lost wages, or lost benefits. Proposed penalties are a fine, up to 10 years in prison, or both for the base offense; a fine, up to 20 years, or both if serious bodily injury results; and a fine, imprisonment for any term of years or life, or both if death results.

Fines would go to the Highway Trust Fund. Rep. Laura Gillen (D-NY) introduced the bill with Reps. Troy Nehls (R-TX), Josh Gottheimer (D-NJ), and Vince Fong (R-CA) listed as cosponsors; the GovInfo record shows referral to the House Judiciary Committee that day.

Practical note: The introduced text proposes a criminal offense and penalties. The proposed section does not expressly set out a private civil remedy; this observation is limited to the bill text and is not legal advice.

Will the Stop Auto Fraud Act Lower My Car Insurance Premium?

No reduction is required or guaranteed. H.R. 10269 is a proposal, not a law, and it sets no rates. Clearspeed estimated $31.6 billion in annual U.S. personal-auto costs from fraud and inaccurate information across claims and underwriting. Insurify reports that the model assumes about 10% of policies involve fraud or misrepresentation and losses equal to about 15% of premiums linked to those policies. This is a model, not a count of confirmed fraud, and it covers more than staged crashes. Insurance Journal attributes a separate estimate of up to $300 a year in added premiums from staged-crash fraud to NICB; the methodology was not available. Neither figure estimates savings from H.R. 10269.

$300 NICB estimate of possible annual premium impact from staged-crash fraud, as reported by Insurance Journal; not bill-specific
$31.6B Clearspeed model estimate for fraud and inaccurate information in U.S. personal-auto insurance; not confirmed losses
43,811 Suspected motor vehicle insurance-fraud incidents reported by insurers to New York DFS in 2025; 80% above 2020

Neither the $300 figure nor the $31.6 billion model estimates an individual driver’s likely savings. New York’s 43,811 reports were suspected motor-vehicle insurance-fraud incidents reported by insurers to DFS in 2025, 80% more than in 2020—not confirmed fraud findings or staged crashes alone. Any premium effect would depend on enactment, enforcement, fraud deterred, insurers’ costs, and state rate rules. The sources reviewed provide no bill-specific savings estimate.

What the bill does
Creates a federal crime Proposal
Up to 10 years; 20 for serious bodily injury; life possible if death results
The introduced text covers knowingly executing or attempting a scheme to cause, stage, fabricate, or simulate a crash and submit a false, fictitious, or fraudulent insurance claim. These are proposed penalties, not current law.
What the bill does not do
Does not set rates No cap
No rate cap or premium-reduction mandate
The introduced bill does not set premiums or require insurers to reduce them. It also specifies no effective date.

Estimate Your Car Insurance Costs

Use the site’s estimator to review an indicative rate for your profile. Results are estimates, not binding quotes from insurers, and your actual price depends on underwriting.

GET YOUR CAR INSURANCE QUOTES

Who Could Be Affected by the Stop Auto Fraud Act?

The bill is federal but gives no state-by-state findings or estimate of which drivers might benefit. Insurance Journal reported that trucking-industry supporters described commercial trucks as targets of staged crashes; this is supporters’ rationale, not an estimate of the bill’s effect.

The bill does not single out coverage types. It lists false claims for medical treatment, repairs, lost wages, or lost benefits, but would not itself change policy terms or coverage limits.

What Should Drivers Do Now About the Stop Auto Fraud Act?

Do not change coverage decisions based on this proposal. Review your current policy and compare the premium, limits, and deductibles with your needs.

Check your renewal notice
See if your premium changed and why
Compare with the prior term. Ask your insurer what changed and whether discounts or coverage adjustments apply.
Review your deductibles and limits
A higher deductible may reduce the premium
A higher deductible means more out-of-pocket cost on a covered claim. Any premium effect depends on the policy; make sure you can afford it.
Verify uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage
May help in eligible cases with an uninsured or underinsured driver
UM/UIM coverage depends on state law and policy terms. Ask whether it is available or required in your state, and review limits and exclusions with your insurer.
Report suspected fraud
Contact your insurer and check your state’s reporting process
Document what happened, preserve photos or dashcam footage if available, notify your insurer, and follow your state’s reporting process. One driving behavior or injury claim does not by itself prove fraud.

How we verified this article

We reviewed the introduced H.R. 10269 text on GovInfo, New York DFS’s April 8, 2026 release, Insurance Journal (September 18, 2026), Clearspeed (August 13, 2026), Insurify (September 18, 2026), and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners’ consumer guide to auto insurance for the UM/UIM coverage note. GovInfo lists introduction and referral to the House Judiciary Committee on September 3 as the latest displayed action. The $31.6 billion figure is a model estimate based on assumptions described by Insurify; the $300 figure is attributed to NICB by Insurance Journal, but its methodology was unavailable. New York’s 43,811 reports are suspected incidents, not confirmed fraud findings. No source reviewed estimates savings attributable specifically to H.R. 10269. Confirm the live bill record before publication for later status changes.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Stop Auto Fraud Act

Will the Stop Auto Fraud Act lower my car insurance premium?

No. H.R. 10269 is a proposal, not law. It sets no rates and requires no premium reduction; the sources reviewed provide no estimate of the savings it would produce.

What does the Stop Auto Fraud Act actually do?

The bill would create a federal offense for knowingly causing, staging, fabricating, or simulating a vehicle accident as part of a scheme to submit a fraudulent insurance claim. Proposed imprisonment is up to 10 years, up to 20 years if serious bodily injury results, and any term of years or life if death results. Fines would go to the Highway Trust Fund.

When would the Stop Auto Fraud Act take effect?

The introduced text specifies no effective date and is not law. H.R. 10269 was introduced and referred to the House Judiciary Committee on September 3, 2026. Check GovInfo for any later action.

The Bottom Line for Drivers

The Stop Auto Fraud Act remains a proposal intended to deter staged-crash fraud; the GovInfo record reviewed lists it as introduced and referred to the House Judiciary Committee. It specifies no effective date and does not require insurers to lower rates.

Its next steps, final text, and any effect on premiums remain unknown. No bill-specific savings estimate was found, so drivers should not expect a quick or guaranteed rate cut.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and is not professional insurance, legal or financial advice. Rates, rules and deadlines vary by insurer, state and driver, and can change. Confirm details with a licensed agent, your insurer or your state department of insurance before making a coverage decision.

Sources

Last updated: